Introduction
Currently, a little more than half of the Member States of the European Union, that is, 15 out of 27, recognize and permit same-sex marriage. The remaining 12 still do not admit this form of marriage in their domestic legal systems. Jurisprudential developments in this field are therefore particularly significant.
On 25 November 2025, the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) delivered its judgment in Case C-713/23, Wojewoda Mazowiecki, extending to marriage records its existing case law on the recognition, by other Member States, of civil-status acts obtained in another EU country, such as surname registration or gender identity amendments (notably the Pancharevo judgment of 14 December 2021).
The judgment concerns situations in which the Member State of origin, meaning the State of birth, does not recognize same-sex marriages. The ruling strengthens the protection of the rights to family life and ensures that the exercise of free movement and residence within the EU is not undermined by discriminatory administrative practices.
The Court held that Member States must recognize same-sex marriages validly celebrated in another Member State when such marriage results from the exercise of free movement rights and when family life has been established in that other State.
Background of the case
Until 2018, CJEU case law, specifically the Coman ruling, required Member States to recognize such marriages solely for the purposes of free movement, without imposing consequences on internal personal-status law. In 2025, however, the Court found that the complete absence of recognition in the Member State of origin constitutes a restriction on the rights to free movement and residence and significantly affects the right to family life.
The case arose from a request for a preliminary ruling (a mechanism through which national courts ask the CJEU to interpret EU law) submitted by the Polish Supreme Administrative Court, which asked the CJEU two core questions:
- Whether a Member State whose legal order does not allow marriage between persons of the same sex may refuse to recognize a marriage celebrated in another Member State.
- Whether it may also refuse the transcription (registration of the foreign marriage) in the national civil register, where transcription is necessary to produce internal legal effects or to allow the exercise of rights in another Member State where the spouses intend to reside.
Legal basis of the decision (EU)

The reasoning is based, in particular, on:
- Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, on Union citizenship and the right to free movement and residence (Articles 20 and 21);
- Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union, which protect private and family life and prohibit discrimination, including on grounds of sexual orientation (Articles 7 and 21).
Decision and main grounds
The Court concluded that refusing recognition or transcription breaches EU law, since it prevents or makes excessively difficult the exercise of rights deriving from free movement and seriously affects the right to family life.
Three pillars stand out:
- Effectiveness of EU rights: forcing spouses to live as if unmarried in the Member State of origin, and, consequently, in any other Member State where they seek to reside, undermines the effectiveness of the rights of movement and residence.
- Proportionality and non-discrimination: national administrative practices cannot create disproportionate obstacles to the exercise of those rights, nor introduce distinctions based on sexual orientation.
- Transcription as a necessary means: when transcription is the only existing mechanism to produce internal legal effects essential to the exercise of rights provided for under EU law, it must be carried out without discrimination in relation to marriages validly celebrated in other Member States.
Limits and scope of the decision

The judgment does not require Member States to substantively recognize same-sex marriage under their domestic law. The definition of marriage and civil-status rules remains, in principle, within the sphere of national competence.
However, the CJEU held that the exercise of this competence must comply with EU law. States’ margin of discretion cannot justify denying a civil-status act validly established in another Member State when such denial compromises the effectiveness of the rights to free movement and family life. Thus, where no other effective mechanism exists, States must make transcription available, without discrimination, without this implying recognition of same-sex marriage for purposes of domestic law.
Relationship with European case law

The decision is in line with the case law of the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR), notably the judgments in Przybyszewska and Others v. Poland and Fedotova and Others v. Russia, both from 2023, through which the ECtHR has ruled on States’ positive obligation to provide a legal framework offering same-sex couples adequate recognition and protection.
Likewise, the CJEU further develops the path begun with the Coman case (C-673/16) referred to here, contributing to legal certainty for same-sex couples in the Union.
Practical implications
- For couples:
The judgment allows the change in personal status resulting from a marriage celebrated in another Member State to be recognized in the Member State of origin and, consequently, in any other Member State where they intend to reside, ensuring continuity of their family life.
- For national authorities:
It requires a review of civil-registration procedures to avoid discriminatory practices and remove administrative obstacles that may compromise the effectiveness of free movement, with proportionate and non-discriminatory criteria to be adopted.
Conclusion

This judgment represents a significant step forward in protecting families formed by same-sex couples within the European Union. By ensuring that the exercise of the rights to free movement and residence does not lose effectiveness through discriminatory administrative practices, the CJEU reinforces legal certainty and equality in everyday European life.
The Court demonstrates that the balance between national competence over civil status and the effectiveness of EU law requires administrative mechanisms that effectively and non-discriminatorily ensure recognition of the essential effects of civil-status acts validly constituted in another Member State.
Official source
Judgment of the Court of Justice (Grand Chamber) of 25 November 2025
Follow-up note
The administrative application of this decision may require internal guidelines from each Member State. We will update this article once the full judgment and any national instructions become available.
It remains to be seen whether States, such as Poland, will adopt transcription procedures identical to those applicable to heterosexual marriages or will create alternative pathways specifically directed at same-sex marriages.